34 Comments

Thumb default avatar
Yasin Ghulam almost 2 years ago

Indeed to participate in the advancement of sciences and innovation, we have to put our weight and effort as we can do for the betterness of successor and  community. 

Thumb default avatar
Muhammad Naeem Nizam almost 2 years ago

I want to pay my contribution in the bright future of science and humanity.

Thumb default avatar
Md. Galal Uddin almost 2 years ago

Really, I will try to engage as a peer reviewer

Thumb default avatar
Israel Borokini over 1 year ago

I think academic quality check is the most important reason for peer review. I have seen very annoying mistakes in published papers out there! I wondered if the peer reviewers really did the job they were supposed to do

Thumb default avatar
Aydin ashrafi over 1 year ago

It is true that peer review made us to be up to date and it brings some lights in our brain to think very deep in our field

Thumb 20180101 002334

Honestly, it wasn't a selfish answer 

Thumb 02  2
Srikanth H N over 1 year ago

realy agreed for above statement. It will improve our knowledge about the field we are dealing.

Thumb profile 1

It is only the need for give a gift to mankind 

Thumb default avatar
Sunil Kumar over 1 year ago

thanks for this informative video  and knowledge 

Thumb img 20181030 163146 01 01
Celia Fortuna Rodrigues over 1 year ago

Thas is, actually, very honest and true for me too.

Thumb default avatar
Dr Dinesh Uthra over 1 year ago

Peer review gives the deep knowledge about any  field of research.

Thumb ghla
Duong Van Tuyen over 1 year ago

I like the way you explain about your selfish, the meaningful selfish those.

Thumb default avatar
LAL DEVAYANI VASUDEVAN NAIR over 1 year ago

Dr.George booth gives an honest reason , which is true for most. At the end of it we do not read all the material published how much ever so called "well read"we are. This process gives us an in-depth idea, at least during the process of review.

Thumb default avatar
Manica Negahdaripour over 1 year ago

A useful video. The points mentioned in the video, shows how he approaches a reviewing task, which is also useful for other reviewers.

Thumb default avatar
Srinivasan Jayaraman over 1 year ago

Can you please remove the word reproduce, it really does conveys a different meaning.

overall a thoughtful one.

Thumb 20180118 205730 01
Atul Munish Chander over 1 year ago

I am thankful to Nature for providing this course but I wonder that none of the video is playing as I tried different web servers with high speed internet.

Thumb default avatar
Ankita awasthi over 1 year ago

the process enhances our knowledge and way of thinking

Thumb default avatar
Adamkolo Mohammed Ibrahim over 1 year ago

I agree with you through peer review one stands to gain a lot of experience and knowledge about research and methods. 

Thumb default avatar
Marie Claude Fadous Khalife about 1 year ago

It is really selfish

Thumb default avatar
Raimi Morufu Olalelan about 1 year ago

It keeps me to be more current and informative

Thumb default avatar
Gabriela Perez Tort about 1 year ago

I think Dr George Booth is right because we are faced every day to many papers we read very too quickly, as peer reviewer we must see from the eyes of different authors at first, this  must be detailed and takes a certain time ,  then consider whether the research could or not be bettered in any way. We have to make what  Rose calls" Immersion"

Thumb default avatar
SUDHEESH RAVI about 1 year ago

Peer review process is a rigorous one and need most intelligence to grasp the content in the paper.

Thumb default avatar
SANTOSH KUMAR BHASKAR 11 months ago

selfishness revealed beautifully  by  the faculty in the videos

Thumb kamuyu mwai
Kamuyu Mwai 10 months ago

Well...peer reviewing demands an open mind full of commitment.

Thumb default avatar
Raghed ibrahim esmaeel 10 months ago

 i agree with Dr.George about his opinion. Peer review needs to understand his/ her major of paper because there are many type sciences. Also,  peer review needs explaining why this paper accepted in addition to why this paper rejection.  

Thumb default avatar
Evelyn Cermeno 10 months ago

Thumb default avatar
José Veiga 9 months ago

Very interesting particular point of view. You just show me others advantages of peer-reviewing. I love it. 

Thumb default avatar
gaurav kapoor 9 months ago

i liked the content and the way it was explained.

Thumb img 20180217 225108
Mr. Pravin Deharkar 6 months ago

I think academic quality check is the most important reason for peer review. I have seen very annoying mistakes in published papers out there! I wondered if the peer reviewers really did the job they were supposed to do

Thumb img 20180217 225108
Mr. Pravin Deharkar 6 months ago

really agreed for above statement. It will improve our knowledge about the field we are dealing.

Thumb oyetoro oyebode stephen

The very fact that he said he did peer review for selfish reasons are the choicest words he could use. Peer reviews are beneficial to all the parties concerned and the community of practice. Our initial stances and bias about science are refined by dint of the peer review process. What more than the learning therein for all the parties involved.

Thumb default avatar
Prathibha M.P 3 months ago

Intresting to be a peer reviewer

Thumb default avatar
Prathibha M.P 3 months ago

Intresting to be a peer reviewer

Thumb default avatar
Natalia Palii 3 months ago

I do completely agree with Dr George Booth