Go to the profile of Yasin Ghulam
Yasin Ghulam over 1 year ago

Positive and encouraging comments are needed that's motivate the author for further modifications or improvements if needed. 

Go to the profile of Muhammad Naeem Nizam
Muhammad Naeem Nizam over 1 year ago

While reviewing a paper, you should be open minded and relaxed so that you can motivate the authors for further advancements. 

Go to the profile of Riccardo Maddalena
Riccardo Maddalena 10 months ago

Thank you for this. it is very helpful. Sometime is hard to keep your tone and I need to read few times my response before submitting 

Go to the profile of Oloyede Oyekola Oluyimika

Aim at constructive criticism.

Go to the profile of Kamuyu Mwai
Kamuyu Mwai 8 months ago

Simple, as i always say (subject to correction), one ought be "decent in thought & deed" (mostly when it comes to literary works & ARTS). So indeed, tone & language need be "decent" considering that the work one is reviewing has been worked-on & presented with utmost care.

Go to the profile of Steven James Newton
Steven James Newton 5 months ago

Encouragement is vital.