49 Comments

Go to the profile of Yasin Ghulam
Yasin Ghulam about 1 year ago

ALRIGHT, The flow diagram given here to describe the whole procedure from submitting to final accepting is well designed and comprehensive understanding in one diagram or flow chart. 

Go to the profile of Katon Kras
Katon Kras 6 months ago

Agreed

Go to the profile of Muhammad Naeem Nizam
Muhammad Naeem Nizam about 1 year ago

Fully understandable flow diagram regarding the procedure of submitting to accepting the articles

Go to the profile of Talat Afreen
Talat Afreen about 1 year ago

clear description of review process in this simple flow diagram  

Go to the profile of Donatella Ponti
Donatella Ponti about 1 year ago

The diagram is clear and describe very well the flow from the submission to accepting of the paper

Go to the profile of Md. Galal Uddin
Md. Galal Uddin about 1 year ago

The flow diagram is present whole procedure of manuscript for production a article.

Go to the profile of Farogh Ahsan
Farogh Ahsan about 1 year ago

The entire procedure has been explained very easily by the help of flowchart

Go to the profile of Dukhu Charan Soren
Dukhu Charan Soren about 1 year ago

Really very good information for peer reviewer beginners and help us in future when assignment is given to us.

Go to the profile of Israel Borokini
Israel Borokini 12 months ago

I have a few questions about this: which part of the process takes the longest? I assume it's the peer reviewer's time, right? Are the reviewers given specific time frame to finish the review process and send their recommendations?

Go to the profile of Fidele Ntie-Kang
Fidele Ntie-Kang 12 months ago

clearly explained 

Go to the profile of Mekhled Alzaza
Mekhled Alzaza 12 months ago

it is essential diagram with fully explained for the role of peer reviewer and process of reviewing and publication papers.

Go to the profile of Aydin ashrafi
Aydin ashrafi 12 months ago

it was very useful.

Go to the profile of samiron sana
samiron sana 12 months ago

It's clear idea to proceed any peer review articles 

Go to the profile of Srikanth H N
Srikanth H N 12 months ago

clearly understood. It is in most comprehensive and simple manner

Go to the profile of Felix Jose  Gonzalez Gonzalez

Nice infographic... 

Go to the profile of Zahra Sepehri
Zahra Sepehri 12 months ago

An organized, time and quality oriented diagram

Go to the profile of Emanuel Vamanu
Emanuel Vamanu 11 months ago

I think is a too long  for acceptance.

Go to the profile of Maribela Pestana
Maribela Pestana 11 months ago

ok

Go to the profile of Kasi Murugan
Kasi Murugan 11 months ago

Good flowchart with highly informative course description

Go to the profile of Thulisile  P. Jaca
Thulisile P. Jaca 11 months ago

Clearly explained!

Go to the profile of Dr. Felix Bongomin
Dr. Felix Bongomin 10 months ago

An exhaustive flow diagram.

Go to the profile of Bhushanavathi Peketi
Bhushanavathi Peketi 10 months ago

understood the entire process of publication in nature

Go to the profile of Dr Dinesh Uthra
Dr Dinesh Uthra 9 months ago

The flow diagram is  well designed , understanding the each element"s roles , gives the duration  of the process.

Go to the profile of LAL DEVAYANI VASUDEVAN NAIR

Clear description of the process involved. over all a clear process chart reducing the jargon, well written

Go to the profile of Benedito Barraviera
Benedito Barraviera 9 months ago

The flow is very explanatory.

Go to the profile of Manica Negahdaripour
Manica Negahdaripour 9 months ago

A very clear flow chart. Thanks.

Go to the profile of Vijay Rakesh Reddy S
Vijay Rakesh Reddy S 8 months ago

Illustration in the flow diagram is very apt and impressive as it is easy to understand.

Go to the profile of Andrea Tenorio Correia da Silva

The flow diagram is very useful and makes the step-by-step of peer review process clear. Thank you!

Go to the profile of Veronica Samedi
Veronica Samedi 8 months ago

Very uptodate information, extremely useful

Go to the profile of Azhar Gaber Shalaby
Azhar Gaber Shalaby 8 months ago

this flow diagram is facilitating the understanding of peer review process, thank you.

Go to the profile of Maria Madjarska-Theissen

Editorial knowledge of the studied matter is essential into taking  the right decision on the truthfulness of the article  and it should not rely solely on the referees comments.  Lees subjective if having 2-3 referees.

Go to the profile of Adamkolo Mohammed Ibrahim

I have been peer reviewing for quite some time now; I think the annotated diagram shown above is graphical representation of the whole review process comprehensively. In fact, for me, that diagram alone suffices as a course. Well done Nature Masterclass. 

Go to the profile of Marcio
Marcio 7 months ago

The flow diagram is very useful and makes the step-by-step of peer review process clear. Thank you!

Go to the profile of Sunyoung Ahn
Sunyoung Ahn 7 months ago

Go to the profile of DHANANJAY KUMAR SAH
DHANANJAY KUMAR SAH 6 months ago

well explained !

Go to the profile of Kiran S Baliyan
Kiran S Baliyan 6 months ago

Was aware but many things got better clarity.

Go to the profile of Mary Mathews
Mary Mathews 5 months ago

Go to the profile of Saartjie Roux
Saartjie Roux 5 months ago

Flow diagram is clear and descriptive

Go to the profile of Ye Htut Linn
Ye Htut Linn 5 months ago

Very simple explanation and great work.

Go to the profile of Dr.S.Senthilkumar
Dr.S.Senthilkumar 5 months ago

The flowchart depicts the clear cut idea on peer review process

Go to the profile of Marie Claude Fadous Khalife

Very Interesting and interesting flow diagram

Go to the profile of Olusanya Temitope
Olusanya Temitope 2 months ago

flow chart was helpful

Go to the profile of SANTOSH KUMAR BHASKAR
SANTOSH KUMAR BHASKAR 2 months ago

peer review  process  depicted.

Go to the profile of Kamuyu Mwai
Kamuyu Mwai about 2 months ago

The diagram is quite clear & eloquent as far as peer reviewing to publication is concerned.

Go to the profile of Raghed ibrahim esmaeel
Raghed ibrahim esmaeel about 1 month ago

i Agree about this flow of peer reviewer, All journals that included indexed by a web of science point out these steps.

Go to the profile of Manish Kumar Asthana
Manish Kumar Asthana 30 days ago

How does editor select the reviewer? and how much time editor take in deciding to accept the manuscript fro review?

Go to the profile of Tien Anh Ngo
Tien Anh Ngo 29 days ago

It is very clear and helpfully for authors who are aiming to submit a manuscript for peer review

Go to the profile of DR. SAUMYA PANDEY
DR. SAUMYA PANDEY 19 days ago

The peer-review process was well-explained and provided critical research insights in successful publication strategies with initial author submission procedures, including double-blind peer-reviewing process in international reputed journals, reviewrs' suggestions/expert comments viz. lacunae and/or missing links in complex data sets, etc. and final publication decision in terms of manuscript acceptance, revision and/or unacceptance/rejection. An enlightening and thought-stimulating session with enriching academic information to sail successfully in my research career on a global platform and publish meaningful research in leading journals with expert review panels/editorial teams.

Go to the profile of Philip Mensah
Philip Mensah 3 days ago

The flow chart is very clear and insightful